Damned Yankees by Ray DeptulaMy rating: 4 of 5 stars
Good History
I struggled with this book. There was a lot happening, which tore me a part. It seemed to me as though a non-fiction history was mashed into a dramatic historical fiction saga muddening both from reaching their full potential. Yet, each had merit, and I couldn’t rectify separating them; they were dependent upon each other.
My praise is that the story blend was well done. It was crucial to have the historical detail for the narrative of the fictional tale. As a historical fiction lover, I appreciated this greatly.
My criticism is that the extraneous detail often deistracted from main story. I can see how casual readers, looking for a clear tale, could be over-whelmed and lose interest. If they just want Jack’s story, all the extra history is wasted and unnecessary.
There are 2 books in 1 here. I enjoyed both, and found it especially interesting with current events, but daunting at times. This isn’t a simple read.
Now, as far as Jack’s story goes, it’s very good. It’s a heartbreaking tale, but also, I was impressed with the surprising relationships that unfolded throughout. I was moved by his life and experiences.
Do I recommend this book? This is hard because I believe this is a good book, and I enjoyed it despite its flaws. However, if I’m honest, I’d say if you’re looking for a crisply written story, no, this book will drive you nuts because it doesn’tstay with Jack. If you enjoy history and a story with rich detail, yes. You’ll appreciate the diversions into the larger world view that creates the situations Jack ends up in.
View all my reviews
J.M. NORTHUP 